(ohio-man-jailed-texting-shreks-penis-state-senator-your-questions-about-shrexting-answered.html)  (https://www.fire.org/themes/custom/fire/assets/pwa/icons/apple-touch-icon.png)         (../themes/custom/fire/assets/pwa/manifest.json)      (../themes/custom/fire/assets/pwa/icons/favicon.ico)  (../themes/custom/fire/assets/pwa/icons/favicon.svg)  (https://www.fire.org/themes/custom/fire/assets/fonts/national/national-thin.woff2)  (https://www.fire.org/themes/custom/fire/assets/fonts/national/national-light.woff2)  (https://www.fire.org/themes/custom/fire/assets/fonts/national/national-medium-italic.woff2)  (https://www.fire.org/themes/custom/fire/assets/fonts/national/national-semibold.woff2)  (https://www.fire.org/themes/custom/fire/assets/fonts/national/national-bold.woff2)  (https://www.fire.org/themes/custom/fire/assets/fonts/pt-sans/PTSans-Regular.woff2)  (https://www.fire.org/themes/custom/fire/assets/fonts/pt-sans/PTSans-Italic.woff2)  (https://www.fire.org/themes/custom/fire/assets/fonts/pt-sans/PTSans-Bold.woff2)  (https://www.fire.org/themes/custom/fire/assets/fonts/pt-sans/PTSans-BoldItalic.woff2)  Ohio man jailed for texting Shrek’s penis to a state senator. Your questions about Shrexting, answered. | The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (../sites/default/files/css/css_pH40hvHamRiVLiHSCGlWD0irAr9M2ao9TeMFZh9NNwQ.css@delta=0&language=en&theme=fire&include=eJxNjVEKQyEMBC8keqQSNfpS1EgSob19BVte_2ZnFzaxYMiyJjQPT3i59CcyQePqCm0VQfFQR1WoqCepgVFyHfc4FGqG4hNMIx5fydgjZl9YOtiu3QSBKjAv_R3dxq8xV2ykF2anbzXs59osP.css)  (../sites/default/files/css/css_YyXRumVbMWCwy5kpNg4stilrXUPtgYT1cThPj9Azjr0.css@delta=1&language=en&theme=fire&include=eJxNjVEKQyEMBC8keqQSNfpS1EgSob19BVte_2ZnFzaxYMiyJjQPT3i59CcyQePqCm0VQfFQR1WoqCepgVFyHfc4FGqG4hNMIx5fydgjZl9YOtiu3QSBKjAv_R3dxq8xV2ykF2anbzXs59osP.css)      (ohio-man-jailed-texting-shreks-penis-state-senator-your-questions-about-shrexting-answered.html#maincontent) Skip to main content   (https://www.fire.org/)           (https://www.fire.org/members/) Member Portal   (https://www.fire.org/students) Students   (https://www.fire.org/faculty) Faculty   (https://www.fire.org/alumni) Alumni   (https://www.fire.org/college-administrators) College Administrators   (https://www.fire.org/about-us) About Us    (https://shop.fire.org/) Store   (https://www.fire.org/submit-a-case) Submit a Case   (https://www.fire.org/get-involved/subscribe-fire-updates) Newsletter   (https://www.fire.org/donate?form=FUNCNZRZALN) Donate     (https://www.fire.org/) Home  (https://shop.fire.org/) Store  (https://www.fire.org/donate?form=FUNCNZRZALN) Donate   Defending Your Rights   What We Do   (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/individual-rights-advocacy) Individual Rights Advocacy  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/reforming-college-policies) Reforming College Policies  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/legal-support) Legal Support  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/legislative-policy-reform) Legislative Policy Reform  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/our-impact) Our Impact     What we defend  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/free-speech) Free Speech  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/academic-freedom) Academic Freedom  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/religious-liberty) Religious Liberty  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/due-process) Due Process  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/press-freedom) Press Freedom  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/freedom-of-assembly) Freedom of Assembly  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/freedom-of-conscience) Freedom of Conscience  (https://www.fire.org/defending-your-rights/title-ix) Title IX     Have your rights been violated?  If you face retaliation over protected speech, reach out to FIRE to learn more about how we can protect your rights.  (https://www.fire.org/submit-a-case) Submit a Case   (College student at an urban city campus)       Get Involved   Make a difference  (https://www.fire.org/get-involved/subscribe-fire-updates) Get FIRE Updates  (https://www.fire.org/get-involved/take-action) Take Action  (https://www.fire.org/donate) Donate  (https://www.fire.org/get-involved/events) Attend an Event  (https://www.fire.org/research-learn/fire-staff-speakers) Host a FIRE Speaker  (https://www.fire.org/get-involved/be-an-advocate) Be an Advocate  (https://www.fire.org/careers) Join Our Team     Subscribe to FIRE Updates  Stay up to date with FIRE's biggest cases and battles for free expression.  (https://www.fire.org/get-involved/subscribe-fire-updates) Subscribe   (Woman speaking through a megaphone)   Take Action  Across the nation, free speech rights are under attack. Join us in defending this essential quality of liberty. Make your voice heard and join a campaign.  (https://www.fire.org/get-involved/take-action) Protect Free Speech   (Take Image graphic with bullhorn)       Research & Learn   Resources  (https://www.fire.org/research-learn) Resource Library  (https://www.fire.org/research-learn?_page=1&keywords=&_limit=6&resource_type=1566) Reports  (https://www.fire.org/research-learn?_page=1&keywords=&_limit=6&resource_type=1559) Issue Pages  (https://www.fire.org/research-learn?_page=1&keywords=&_limit=6&resource_type=1562) Databases  (https://www.fire.org/research-learn?_page=1&keywords=&_limit=6&resource_type=1561) Campus Guides  (https://www.fire.org/research-learn?_page=1&keywords=&_limit=6&resource_type=1560) Toolkits  (https://www.fire.org/research-learn?_page=1&keywords=&_limit=6&resource_type=1567) Books  (https://www.fire.org/supreme-court) Supreme Court Cases     College Free Speech Rankings  This year FIRE and College Pulse surveyed nearly 63,000 students and ranked 261 U.S. colleges and universities. We use real student experiences, university policies, and speech controversies to determine the free speech rankings.  (https://www.fire.org/college-free-speech-rankings) Explore Rankings   (Photo collage showing a student wearing a backpack in black and white against a yellow-tinted background of college buildings and bar graphs)   National Speech Index  The National Speech Index tracks free speech sentiments in America. It is a quarterly survey component of America's Political Pulse from the Polarization Research Lab.  (https://www.fire.org/research-learn/national-speech-index) Learn More   (People standing in a line with speech bubbles above their heads)       (https://www.fire.org/colleges) Colleges   (https://www.fire.org/news) News   (https://www.fire.org/cases) Cases   (https://www.fire.org/submit-a-case) Submit a Case  (https://www.fire.org/get-involved/subscribe-fire-updates) Newsletter            (Enter search terms)       (https://www.fire.org/) Home  (https://www.fire.org/news) Newsdesk         Contents    Table of Contents      Share  (mailto:?subject=From%20Fire.org%20%E2%80%93%20Ohio%20man%20jailed%20for%20texting%20Shrek%E2%80%99s%20penis%20to%20a%20state%20senator.%20Your%20questions%20about%20Shrexting%2C%20answered.&body=Hi%20there%20%E2%80%93%20%0A%0AI%20thought%20you%20would%20be%20interested%20in%20this%20content%20from%20Foundation%20for%20Individual%20Rights%20in%20Expression%3A%0A%0Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.fire.org%2Fnews%2Fohio-man-jailed-texting-shreks-penis-state-senator-your-questions-about-shrexting-answered) Share with Email   Share on Bluesky   Share on Twitter   Share on Facebook   Print     (Decorative background graphic) (Decorative background graphic)   Ohio man jailed for texting Shrek’s penis to a state senator. Your questions about Shrexting, answered.        by  (https://www.fire.org/about-us/our-team/daniel-burnett) Daniel Burnett  (https://www.fire.org/about-us/our-team/aaron-terr) Aaron Terr    June 4, 2026       (Shrek image)  View credit  close  FIRE          Editor's Note: An image of the exchange, including Shrek, was added to this article after its initial publication.  Princess Fiona never complained, but Sen. Jerry Cirino sure did. In May, the Ohio state senator emailed a local police chief, asking him to file criminal charges against a progressive blogger who texted Cirino an image of Shrek… enjoying his swamp stick. The blogger, D.J. Byrnes, runs (https://www.rooster.info/) The Rooster political website.  According to (https://signalohio.org/ohio-republican-senator-called-cops-seeking-charges-against-blogger/) Signal Ohio : The text messages include Byrnes’ political commentary, him calling Cirino his oft-repeated and derisive nickname “Young Mussolini,” and Byrnes plugging his own newsletter. It also contains a digitally altered version of Shrek, the ogre with a titular children’s movie franchise, with his penis exposed. An affidavit with Byrnes’ arrest report refers to the depiction of Shrek as “fully nude with an exposed and erect humanlike penis engaged in an act of masturbation.”  (Shrek dick pic)   No Shrektile Dysfunction there. On May 8, two days after Byrnes sent the texts, (https://www.fire.org/sites/default/files/styles/833xy/public/2026/06/Screenshot%202026-06-04%20at%204.00.04%E2%80%AFPM.png.webp?itok=U0igp4hh) Cirino emailed Kirtland Police Chief Jamey Fisher, “officially filing a complaint” and asking the police to file charges against Byrnes.  Byrnes was arrested on Monday based on what appears to be the three texts.  He was released after 23 hours in jail, (https://www.instagram.com/rooster.info/p/DZGNJk5AQXK/) commenting on Instagram: “I believe that the facts presented in court will show that I’m innocent of the misdemeanor charge of telecommunications harassment.” So . . . can the government prosecute Byrnes for his speech? Let’s look at the facts. What is Byrnes charged with?   Byrnes is charged with (https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-2917.21) telecommunications harassment , punishable by up to (https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-2929.24) six months in jail. To be found guilty, the prosecution must prove that Byrnes sent the texts with the intent to “harass, intimidate, or abuse” Cirino. What does the First Amendment say?  About Shrek’s schlong specifically? Nothing, surprisingly. But it does have a lot to say about speech criticizing government officials — that is, that it lies at the heart of our constitutional protection for free speech. Aside from (https://www.fire.org/research-learn/unprotected-speech-synopsis) very narrow exceptions to the First Amendment, such as (https://www.fire.org/research-learn/how-and-why-true-threats-are-unprotected-speech) true threats or (https://www.fire.org/research-learn/obscenity-exception-first-amendment) obscenity , the government generally cannot punish people for saying things to or about public officials, even if some find the speech offensive, insulting or vulgar. Political speech doesn’t have to be serious or reverent to have First Amendment protection. Is this harassment?  (Byrnes)   The First Amendment also doesn’t protect conduct that amounts to harassment, properly defined. But from the content FIRE has been able to review, this was not punishable harassment.  Enforcing harassment laws stays within constitutional lines when, for example, it focuses on unprotected speech like true threats or a repeated, unwanted course of conduct aimed at invading someone’s privacy or disturbing their peace. Think of someone making dozens of calls in the middle of the night to keep someone awake, or continuing to send dozens of texts day after day after being told repeatedly to stop. But a handful of afternoon texts — including a single image — from one easily blockable number, looks like protected speech, not criminal harassment. Especially absent any apparent request to stop. Is this obscene?  As with harassment, the First Amendment has a high bar before the government can punish or prohibit something as (https://www.fire.org/research-learn/obscenity-exception-first-amendment) legally obscene . And this exception to what the First Amendment protects doesn’t automatically apply to speech that someone finds “disgusting” or “pornographic.” In (https://www.fire.org/supreme-court/miller-v-california) Miller v. California  , the Supreme Court ruled that expression is legally obscene only if it satisfies three elements. First, the material, taken as a whole, must appeal to the “prurient interest” (an excessive interest in sex). Second, it must depict sexual conduct in a patently offensive way as defined by law. And third, the material must lack any serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value. It’s a demanding standard.  View video     (Shrek’s P*nis Got Him Arrested?! #Shrexting)        WATCH VIDEO: An Ohio political blogger spent almost a full day in jail after texting a state senator an image of Shrek's penis.   If a work fails to meet even one of these three elements, the First Amendment protects it. The Shrek image may have been crude or vulgar. But in context, there is no serious argument Byrnes sent it to arouse anyone’s sexual interest, let alone that it satisfies the Miller test. Byrnes sent it to another adult, reportedly accompanied by political commentary describing Cirino as “Young Mussolini.” That’s protected political mockery, not obscenity. So, can you text images of ogres in a state of Shrekstacy?   Before anyone loosens their gumdrop buttons, remember that, as in essentially all First Amendment cases, context and details matter. But from what FIRE has seen, Byrnes should not be facing telecommunications harassment charges.  What should I do if I find myself the victim of unwanted images of Shrekstracurricular activities?  The easiest solution: Block the number. Unless, of course, you’re into that sort of thing.   (https://www.fire.org/news-archive?topic=18) Free Speech  (https://www.fire.org/news-archive?topic=1627) Police Encounters  (https://www.fire.org/news-archive?topic=28) Politicians  (https://www.fire.org/news-archive?topic=47) Social Media  (https://www.fire.org/news-archive?topic=2582) Obscenity     Recent Articles  Get the latest free speech news and analysis from FIRE.      (Venezuela is a cautionary tale w/ Jim Epstein and Germania Rodriguez Poleo)   (https://www.fire.org/news/podcasts/so-speak-free-speech-podcast/venezuela-cautionary-tale-w-jim-epstein-and-germania) Venezuela is a cautionary tale w/ Jim Epstein and Germania Rodriguez Poleo   October 7, 2026  Podcast  For more than half a century, Radio Caracas
Television, or RCTV, broadcast news, sports, comedies, and
telenovelas in Venezuela...       (Stacey Segarra-Bohlinger)   (https://www.fire.org/news/fire-sues-los-angeles-city-council-over-policy-banning-certain-words-during-public-comment) FIRE sues Los Angeles City Council over policy banning certain words during public comment   October 6, 2026   A pair of free speech groups filed a lawsuit on behalf of a Los Angeles resident against the city council after it banned certain words during public meetings, a violation of the First Amendment.       (kid on social media)   (https://www.fire.org/news/blogs/free-speech-dispatch/it-was-never-just-going-be-about-keeping-kids-social-media) It was never just going to be about keeping kids off social media   October 2, 2026   Age-gating teens online was never going to stop with kids. The UK is already promising a more "active interventionist state" for the internet.       (black Jesus)   (https://www.fire.org/news/pepperdine-banned-professor-who-taught-about-black-jesus) Pepperdine banned a professor who taught about a black Jesus   September 30, 2026   Pepperdine promises professors freedom to teach controversial ideas and vigorously debate colleagues. Christina Littlefield is testing that promise.                Related Articles   (https://www.fire.org/news/victory-federal-court-says-ice-threatened-critic-serving-him-warning-notice-over-email) VICTORY: Federal court says ICE threatened critic by serving him with 'Warning Notice' over an email   Press Release    (https://www.fire.org/news/statement-ice-tracked-down-new-york-woman-who-posted-information-she-saw-newspaper-why-her) STATEMENT: ICE tracked down a New York woman who posted information she saw in a newspaper. Why her fight is everyone’s fight.   Statement    (https://www.fire.org/news/victory-tennessee-man-jailed-37-days-trump-meme-wins-835000-settlement-after-first-amendment) VICTORY! Tennessee man jailed 37 days for Trump meme wins $835,000 settlement after First Amendment lawsuit   Press Release    (https://www.fire.org/news/what-fires-critics-get-wrong-about-our-ice-app-lawsuit) What FIRE’s critics get wrong about our ICE app lawsuit   Analysis    (https://www.fire.org/news/why-are-miami-police-questioning-woman-over-facebook-posts) Why are Miami police questioning a woman over Facebook posts?   Op-Ed    (https://www.fire.org/news/cops-showing-your-door-political-facebook-posts-absolutely-intolerable-free-society) Cops showing up at your door for political Facebook posts is absolutely intolerable in a free society   Statement         (https://www.fire.org/)           © 2026 (https://www.fire.org/homepage) Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression P.O. Box 40128Philadelphia, PA 19106  (mailto:fire@fire.org) fire@fire.org (tel:2157173473) 215-717-FIRE Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, FIRE, the flame logo, and Free Speech Makes Free People are registered trademarks of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression. All rights reserved.    (https://www.fire.org/about-us) About Us   (https://www.fire.org/contact-us) Contact Us   (https://www.fire.org/careers) Careers   (https://www.fire.org/submit-a-case) Submit a Case   (https://www.fire.org/privacy-policy) Privacy Statement   (https://www.fire.org/messaging-terms-and-conditions) Terms and Conditions     (https://www.facebook.com/thefireorg) Facebook   (https://x.com/TheFIREorg) Twitter   (https://www.instagram.com/thefireorg) Instagram   (http://www.youtube.com/thefireorg) YouTube   (https://www.tiktok.com/@thefireorg) TikTok     (https://www.fire.org/donate?form=FUNCNZRZALN) Donate         Share  Share this selection on Twitter    (ohio-man-jailed-texting-shreks-penis-state-senator-your-questions-about-shrexting-answered.html#) Share this selection via email